ACLJ Testimony: The Constitution Must Prevail Over Sharia Law
Listen tothis article
Imagine discovering that your spouse divorced you in another country without your knowledge, without serving you with legal papers, and without ever giving you a chance to be heard. Then imagine being told that an American court should simply accept that divorce and give it legal effect here.
This scenario is not a hypothetical. American courts are being confronted with divorce cases based on Sharia law and that raises these precise concerns. And the rule should be simple: The Constitution and American legal principles trump Sharia law. American courts must apply the U.S. Constitution and laws, not Sharia law nor any other religious rules or laws, in making decisions.
That is why the ACLJ submitted testimony supporting Ohio Senate Bill 380.
S.B. 380 protects Ohioans from foreign laws, judgments, decrees, and agreements that violate rights secured by the U.S. Constitution, the Ohio Constitution, federal law, or Ohio’s fundamental public policy. The problem is real. Courts in Ohio and around the country have confronted foreign divorces obtained without notice, unilateral procedures available only to husbands, and decrees threatening a spouse’s rights to property or support. Ohio’s Fifth District, for example, refused to recognize a Sudanese divorce certificate where the wife had never been served. Similar disputes involving foreign Islamic divorce practices, including talaq, have arisen elsewhere.
These cases expose the fundamental distinction at the heart of S.B. 380. Religious liberty does not require an American court to use the coercive power of government to enforce a religious or foreign legal result that violates another person’s constitutional rights.
Nor is this problem limited to Sharia. S.B. 380 does not single out Islam, any other religion, or any particular country. The same rule applies whether a judgment or agreement arises from Sharia, Hindu law, another religious tradition, or an entirely secular foreign legal system. American courts have even refused enforcement of foreign judgments that threatened First Amendment freedoms, including English libel judgments incompatible with American free-speech protections.
Some courts already reach the right result. But currently Ohioans must fight the same battle case by case. And challenging a foreign decree can be burdensome, requiring a vulnerable party to hire counsel, prove inadequate notice or procedures, establish the governing foreign law, and sometimes pursue an appeal simply to preserve rights American law already guarantees. S.B. 380 provides a clear rule from the outset.
American law properly respects foreign judgments and strongly protects religious liberty. But neither principle requires surrendering constitutional rights. A foreign government, religious tribunal, or private agreement should never be able to accomplish through an Ohio court what Ohio itself could not constitutionally do.
The Constitution protects every American (regardless of religion) who stands before an American court, and that protection must never be compromised by the application of foreign or religious law. No law, religious doctrine, or foreign legal system should supersede the Constitution or undermine its guarantees. American law and constitutional protections must remain paramount in our courts – not Sharia law.
